Buying Instagram Followers – Does It Make Sense for Companies?

Should companies buy Instagram followers? More followers mean more reach, attention and pull, which speaks in favour. But what risks do bought followers carry, and can they even do harm? Read all the pros and cons of buying Instagram followers here.
Smartphone with Instagram feed in front of a laptop

Why buy Instagram followers?

Followers: everyone wants them – the more, the better. From private users and influencers to companies, whether small, medium-sized or large. Even in times of quality awareness and “content is king”, the number of followers is still the main quantitative KPI (key performance indicator) for the success (or failure) of a social media presence.

Because even though we often know better: evolution has programmed us to follow the crowd. Where the crowd is, there is safety – and so many people can’t be wrong, can they? So when we notice a page, our first glance – often quite unconsciously – goes to the number of followers. If it is high, we are more likely to follow too. If it is low, we may think twice or even question the company’s professionalism and quality.

The fact is: a successful social media presence has three main KPIs:

  1. Number of followers
  2. Interaction rate (number of likes)
  3. Content

And yes, unfortunately in that order. Think of the whole thing as a pyramid – or better still, an iceberg: without good content at the base, you won’t generate interactions or followers, and sooner or later the whole construction collapses. But the number of followers is, unfortunately, the proverbial tip that we see at first glance (and judge, consciously or unconsciously).

The video marketing handbook (in German)

An overview of video marketing in a practical eBook:

“The video marketing handbook” (in German) – download the free eBook here.

Smartphone on a table with like and follower tags
Likes and followers on social media profiles suggest success.

That’s why more and more companies are asking themselves: should we buy Instagram followers?

The moral and PR answer is, of course, “no”, while the marketer or business graduate in us asks: “Why not, actually?” So let’s take an objective look at the advantages and disadvantages of buying social media followers – and what else you can do instead.

Where can you buy Instagram followers?

Let’s assume for a moment that you have already done your research thoroughly and are determined to buy followers. The purchase works through two main tools:

  1. Apps
  2. Websites

In other articles, for example our knowledge articles on brand videos, film production or social media, we link to external websites at this point. But since we don’t support buying followers, we won’t do so here.

With apps, you need a smartphone to buy followers and have to download the relevant app(s). Purchases are made via in-app payment, from where you are usually taken to a payment page and pay by credit card. Websites sometimes offer more payment options.

You can find the apps in the app store and the websites through a Google search (similar to the one you typed in to find this article 😉 ). In both cases, make sure the provider is as reputable as possible – or at least as reputable as you can be with a business model in a grey area … Because there are:

How a brand video creates a strong brand image

Risks of buying followers

Buying followers carries some considerable risks, of which a loss of credibility with your target group is the smallest. Of course, bought followers also have advantages: bigger numbers next to your profile picture, more apparent success (at first glance; more on this below) and perhaps more recognition from your boss or competitors. But that’s pretty much it.

On the other side are the following risks:

  • Loss of credibility
  • Damage to your image
  • Viruses or malware
  • Credit card fraud
  • Deletion of your account

Wait – what?! Yes, really. Let’s talk briefly about the risks of buying followers for social media. Loss of credibility and damage to your image when your target group and “real” followers find out – fair enough. You can fix that again once you post really good content and gather real followers.

But as already mentioned: not all providers of business models in a legal grey area are really reliable – certainly not by the standards we Germans like to apply, for which we are both appreciated and smiled at abroad.

If even apps like Facebook and Messenger are repeatedly viewed critically by data protection advocates (link to verbraucherzentrale.de, the German consumer advice centre, in German) because they could spy on our smartphones, the apps and providers mentioned above are subject to even less control through public interest than giants like Facebook and Google. So you never know what data the app collects and who it passes it on to. As a general rule: “free” stopped existing long ago. “Free” simply means that you don’t pay for using an app with money, but with your user, phone and advertising data.

What happens after the purchase?

Another risk: let me briefly explain how the bought followers find their way to your profile. By linking your Instagram profile with the app or website – including your password. At this point at the latest, even someone who only changes their password every two years from “12345” to “54321” should give it a second thought. The same of course applies to the bank or credit card details you use for payment.

Regardless of everything the apps can do in your name, Facebook, Instagram and co. reacted to this security gap long ago and block profiles that use external apps or bots – sometimes without warning and in every area. We have seen influencers with several hundred thousand followers deleted, but also private profiles with just a few hundred.

So ask yourself: “Is the apparent success of my page worth the risk?”

What you should know about video marketing

An overview of advantages, options and examples

Disadvantages of bought followers

But let’s assume you have found a reputable provider and successfully bought followers. Your smartphone hasn’t been hacked, your credit card details are still safe and your account still belongs to you. Is the way now clear for success, fame and glory?

Not quite. Even after successfully buying followers, there are still disadvantages to consider:

  • Low (= implausible) interaction rates
  • Dubious follower profiles
  • Diluted target group

My honest advice: take two steps back to the goal you originally wanted to achieve with the social media channel (Facebook, Instagram or others). Simply to “be there”? Then bought followers are definitely worth considering and can’t do any harm.

But if you really want to achieve communication and marketing goals – for example, using the channel as a recruiting platform to find new applicants, or as a feeder to your online shop, your website or your email newsletter – what good are dead accounts to you? It’s like buying address lists for your next acquisition mailing that only contain shell companies in the Seychelles.

Because bought followers are mostly fake profiles that nobody ever uses.

(The rest are real users who buy followers themselves by following other profiles with their own profile and earning points for it, which they can use to pay without money.) But you don’t necessarily want to count these users among your followers either, do you?

Back to business: bought followers have two crucial disadvantages for you that really cost you money. First: low interaction rates. This means the ratio between followers and “likes” per post.

Second: a diluted target group. Facebook (and therefore also Instagram) has developed one of the most advanced algorithms for ad targeting. At the time of writing, this meant you could actually show your nappy advert only to women between 25 and 35 who had been pregnant or given birth in the last 6 months – or your job advert for a mechanical engineer to recent graduates whose hobbies are Lego and Fischertechnik. (Leaving aside how creepy it is that Facebook knows such things about us. As marketers, we can use this data to our advantage.)

Of course, this only works – or at least works much more easily – if you have a clearly defined target group that doesn’t consist only of fake profiles.

How a commercial creates enthusiasm for your brand

Alternatives to buying followers

You have made it this far, which means you seem genuinely interested in building an authentic social media profile with a sustainable strategy for success. So let’s talk about what you can do for a successful profile instead of buying followers.

Buying likes

Admittedly, I am only including this point for the sake of completeness, because buying likes isn’t really more reputable either. The risks are the same too (and usually so are the apps), but if you do buy followers, you should also think about interaction rates and therefore invest in likes as well. Now to real alternatives:

Follow for follow

A somewhat frowned-upon but still effective way of gaining new followers is so-called “follow for follow”. In principle: you follow profiles and they follow you back. It’s comparable to good old cold calling, except that instead of picking up the phone, you press buttons on your smartphone.

I have seen numerous company profiles build up several thousand followers in a very short time this way, who actually became a genuinely interested community. Because done well, follow for follow isn’t a negative way of ingratiating yourself, but a guaranteed visible “Hello, here I am” to potential customers and an invitation to look at your profile – and perhaps to stay.

For follow for follow to work, however, you have to think in terms of your target group here too, just as with good cold calling: only follow profiles of users who fit your target group – people you believe or know might like your content.

How companies can improve their image.

Content, quality, personality

Remember the pyramid from above? Good content is the basis for growth on social media, whether Facebook, Instagram or other networks. That’s why you should first create a good social media strategy and a content plan.

Why good content is so important

Social media is just like real life: it’s about relationships, and you build them over the long term through authenticity, personality and reliability. That’s why good content is so important. After all, your social media profile is part of your public image and therefore carries your image.

A good content strategy includes punchy texts, aesthetic photos and short videos. The content depends on your goals and your corporate identity. Popular topics include your products or their applications, employee portraits and snapshots of everyday life, best practices and customer opinions – or a mix of everything.

Conclusion: should companies buy followers?

Only you can decide whether you want to buy followers. Our advice: don’t, because it isn’t worth it. Bought followers are usually dead accounts that lower your interaction rates and dilute your target group for advertising.

Yes, the number of followers is still a driving quantitative KPI in evaluating social media channels. And yes, it is difficult to grow a new page. But it is even more difficult to clean an existing page of dead accounts and make a fresh start with good content and a genuine following.

Whatever you decide: we wish you every success with your social media activities.

Thank you for reading this article! Our goal at Pathfinder Studios is to make you even more successful with video marketing. If we can support you with that, contact our experts at any time for a no-obligation consultation.

We would be delighted if you find more inspiration for successful video marketing on this blog or in our free downloads.

If you would like to go deeper into the topic of online marketing, I recommend the following articles:

YouTube marketing – success with online videos
Inbound marketing – what is it and how do companies benefit?
Interactive video – how viewers become customers
Video marketing statistics – the most compelling data and facts

The brand video handbook (in German) free eBook
The comprehensive introduction to video marketing (in German) free eBook

  • Porträt von Yvonne Schwalowski / Ivy Thomas, Produzentin, Drehbuchautorin und Autorin bei Pathfinder Studios

    Yvonne Schwalowski is a producer, screenwriter and author at Pathfinder Studios and the author of several novels, published by Piper among others. With B2B experience since 2008 and successful multimedia projects for 450+ clients, she is an experienced marketing expert for European companies – from tech start-ups and hidden-champion industrial companies to corporations such as MAN, Miele and Audi. Her short films have won several international awards, and her first international feature film, co-written and co-produced with Tom Wolt, is currently being completed.
    Wikipedia – Portfolio – LinkedIn – IMDb